Some people say that DSA is a “backdoor” into a good school. Personally, I don’t agree with that view, and I think it’s worth being cautious about adopting that kind of mindset. In my opinion, DSA shouldn’t be used just to secure a spot in a prestigious school. It’s important to think about whether the child is truly suited for the commitment and expectations that come with it.

For example, when a student enters through DSA for sports, they usually have to train intensively (often three times a week) and are expected to represent the school in competitions. At the same time, they still need to manage their academic workload. That can be a lot for any 13-year-old. What many people may not realise is that once a child gets into a school via DSA, they’re usually required to remain in that CCA for all four years. Unless the child is really passionate, talented, and ready for the demands, it might not be the best path.

I’ve come across real-life stories where the DSA route ended up being more stressful than rewarding. One student entered through sports DSA, only to discover that her teammates were far more advanced. She felt like the weakest in the team, and both her coach and teammates were unhappy with her performance. The pressure took a toll on her emotionally, and she struggled to keep up with her studies. She wanted to quit the CCA but couldn’t. She eventually had to transfer schools just to get out of the commitment. Sadly, I’ve heard a few other similar stories over the years.

That’s why I personally feel that DSA should only be considered if the child shows genuine interest, has the ability, and is mentally and emotionally prepared for what’s ahead. 

In my daughter’s case, we didn’t consider DSA. She had a wide range of interests in primary school, changing CCA every year. Academically, she was strong in Math and Science, but I still chose not to explore DSA options in those subjects. I felt that secondary school itself would already be demanding, and I preferred that she have time to enjoy her growing-up years, explore freely, and learn at her own pace, without unnecessary pressure.

From what I’ve seen, going into DSA with a “try your luck” mindset can also backfire. Preparing for DSA interviews or auditions can take a lot of time (and sometimes money) which might be better spent on PSLE prep. Since the DSA application and interview period overlaps with the critical revision months before PSLE, it can add even more stress. And if the child ends up not getting a DSA offer, it could affect their confidence or mood just before the exams.

Another common regret I’ve heard from other parents is that once you accept a DSA offer, it’s a done deal, before PSLE results are released. Some children ended up scoring better than expected and could have gotten into their actual dream school through the regular posting route, but they had already committed to a DSA place that wasn’t their top choice.

In the end, I feel that DSA is best for children who are not only passionate and talented about the specific area they’re applying for, but also academically aligned with the school's standard, and truly excited about joining that particular school. I personally don’t see it as an “insurance” or backup option. The pressure of juggling school, CCA commitments, and adolescence is real, and mental well-being should never be compromised.

One last thing: I even heard of a case where a child only found out that her parents had submitted a DSA application on her behalf just before the interview. I honestly feel that decisions like these should be discussed openly. It’s so important that both parent and child are on the same page.

I'm just sharing my thoughts here, and I completely understand that everyone’s situation and perspective is different. What worked for my family may not apply to yours, and that’s perfectly okay. If you’re thinking about DSA, I’d just gently encourage you to take time to consider what’s best for your child, in both the short and long term.



Back to My Views, Experiences, and Reflections on the Primary School Journey